Bonello's New York Pizza

JJAJZ Handyman a month ago

They had the perfect blend of pizza sauce and cheese with the pepperoni. I got a medium so that's why 4 star the crust was a little too thick but I am giving the benefit of a doubt due to it being a medium.The pizza loving kid gave it a 2 thumbs up !

Roger McCort 4 months ago

SHORT VERSION: New York style pizza on the left coast! Very good, decent prices, okay small dining area (but you get a slice to go, right?) LONG VERSION: I found this place by accident while looking for something less typical when I was in town for a conference. Bonello's popped up on my search and had decent reviews, so I thought I'd give it a try. I was hungry, so I ordered two slices and a Diet Coke. Let me tell you the two things that were wrong. The slices each fit on a paper plate. A real New York slice would hang off the plate. But these were a good size, so that's not really a complaint about anything but the look of the slice. Second problem is even more nit-picky and meaningless! Each slice was cut down the middle. We'll, that's not right! A NY slice isn't cut, it's meant to be folded. But this place is in California, so the probably don't get a lot of customers who are familiar with the fold. Maybe they are just catering to their clients expectations. Why do I mention these two things up front? Because the pizza and the service were freakin' awesome! I could have been stopping in any corner joint in the big apple. They took care of me (and the dozen or so other custo

Medical Unicorn 3 years ago

Not the friendliest nor helpful employees. The menu on the board was hard to see and no other menus were available so I didn’t know what they had other than pizza but heard another customer order antipasto. I asked for one slice of mushroom and one of plain. I received four slices which explains the price. The crust was NOT like NY pizza at all. Instead, it was doughy and buttery like a buttered roll. The rest however, was pretty close to NY pizza but not quite. They would NOT provide parmesan to go so I had to use the common one container for everyone before I took my take out order. No idea about drinks as I couldn’t see the fountain. Atmosphere is blasé. Overall it was good but not great nor authentic NY pizza.

Jonathan Zapata 3 years ago

I ordered two cheese pizza slices and a drink for lunch. Everyone at Bonello's was friendly, and the prices are great. The crust was thin and flavorful. The cheese and tomato sauce were well portioned. I enjoyed it and recommend for a New York style pizza.

Ron Khoury 5 years ago

In the quest to find a good NY style pizza place in the South Bay we decided to try this spot. Curbside Service was prompt and quick. They took our order over the phone and were informative on the pizza sizes and such. The dough was good. Cheese and herbs seasoning were good. It wasn’t stretchy or stringy but it hd a good flavor. Tomato sauce was good as well. Not a lot of flop. Not 100% NY style but I’d order it again. It was good and had a good flavor and texture.